· Decision of the Complaints Committee 00351-15 - Ata-Amonoo v Bristol Post
Summary of complaint
1. Ama Ata-Amonoo complained to the Independent Press
Standards Organisation that The Bristol Post had breached Clause 3 (Privacy)
and Clause 5 (Intrusion into grief or shock) of the Editors’ Code of Practice
in an article headlined “Jobless man took life after split-up”, published in
print and online on 2 December 2014.
2. The article reported on the inquest proceedings
relating to the death of the complainant’s brother.
3. The complainant was concerned that the article disclosed
her brother’s full address, his employment situation and details of his private
life and relationship. She said that in
a case involving personal grief and shock, the use of the word “jobless” in the
headline, and the inclusion of these details was insensitive. In addition, she
was concerned that the article intruded on her brother’s privacy. She said that
she and other members of her family had been assured by the reporter attending
the inquest that if an article on the inquest were to be written, it would be
in the public interest, and that the family’s wishes would be respected. She
said that her sister visited the newspaper’s offices, and was assured that no
article would be published, and that contrary to this assurance, an article was
published the following day. She said that it was not in the public interest
for the newspaper to report on the inquest proceedings in the manner in which
it did.
4. The newspaper said that the complainant’s brother’s
address, employment, and the details about his personal life were disclosed as
part of inquest proceedings. It said that in response to the complainant’s
request that the inquest was not reported on, its reporter explained that it
was unlikely that the inquest would not be reported, but that she would ask the
news editor. The reporter passed on the family’s request, but the news editor
decided to publish the report. When the complainant’s sister visited the
newspaper’s office to enquire about whether the article would be published, she
was told that it would be.
Relevant Code Provisions
5. Clause 3 (Privacy)
i.) Everyone is entitled to respect for his or her
private and family life, home, health and correspondence, including digital
communications.
ii.) Editors will be expected to justify intrusions into
any individual's private life without consent. Account will be taken of the
complainant's own public disclosures of information.
Clause 5 (Intrusion into grief or shock)
i.) In cases involving personal grief or shock, enquiries
and approaches must be made with sympathy and discretion and publication
handled sensitively. This should not restrict the right to report legal
proceedings, such as inquests.
ii.) When reporting suicide, care should be taken to
avoid excessive detail about the method used.
Findings of the Committee
6. The Committee expressed its sympathy to the
complainant for the death of her brother. However, the details of her brother’s
personal life, his employment and the circumstances surrounding his death were
given as part of inquest proceedings, and in the absence of reporting
restrictions, these were a matter of public record that the newspaper was
entitled to report on. Reporting these
details did not raise a breach of Clause 3 (Privacy).
7. The Committee acknowledged that the family found the
inclusion of the deceased’s personal details was upsetting and not to be in the
public interest. However, the article was not derogatory, and Clause 5
(Intrusion into grief or shock) makes clear that it should not restrict the
right to report legal proceedings, such as inquests. The Committee was unable
to reconcile the two accounts of the contact between the complainant’s family
and the newspaper prior to publication. Nevertheless, it took the view that, in
the circumstances, the publication of the article was not insensitive, and
there was no breach of Clause 5.
Conclusions
8. The complaint was not upheld.
Remedial Action Required
N/A
Date complaint received: 16/01/2015
Date decision issued: 22/05/2015