Resolution
Statement – 11820-21 Thomson v heraldscotland.com
Summary
of Complaint
1. Michelle
Thomson MSP complained to the Independent Press Standards Organisation that
heraldscotland.com breached Clause 1 (Accuracy) of the Editors’ Code of
Practice in an article headlined “MSPs holding second jobs using Holyrood for
‘hobby’ says Labour”, published on November 15th 2021.
2. The
article reported that “Scottish Labour has accused MSPs who have second jobs of
‘serving the people as a part-time hobby’ after it was revealed that eight
Holyrood politicians top up their salaries with extra employment”. The article
stated that “seven Scottish Conservative MSPs and one SNP MSP had second jobs”.
It listed the seven Conservative MSPs and then stated that “SNP MSP Michelle
Thomson, who was elected to Holyrood in May, is a ‘sole trader of’… a property
investment company, according to her register of interests”. It said she was
“also a director of a property management company”. It then described the
“second jobs” of the Conservative MSPs. The article quoted “Scottish Labour
business manager Neil Bibby” who said that “[t]his is nothing other than the
same Tory sleaze we have seen revealed at Westminster in recent weeks. ‘It is
high time that Douglas Ross… clamped down on these MSPs who view serving the
people as a part-time hobby.”
3. The
article also appeared online in substantially the same format under the
headline “Scottish Labour claims MSPs with second jobs as using Holyrood 'as a
part-time hobby'”.
4. The
complainant said that the article was inaccurate in breach of Clause 1 because
the article was unclear what was meant by the term “second job”. She said the
definition of the word “job” was “a paid position of regular employment” and
this could be applied to the term “second job”. Bearing this definition in
mind, the complainant said that several SNP MSPs had second jobs. She said she
did not have a second job but owned buy-to-let properties that were managed by
a separate company.
5. The
publication did not accept a breach of the Code. It said the complainant’s
entry in the Register of Interests described her role with language that
suggested an occupation, such as “role” of a “sole trader” and “director”. It
said the article had quoted from her entry and, therefore, made clear the
nature of this work. The publication said it had contacted the SNP’s Head of
Communications to ask if he wished to provide a comment, and were told “We will
not be adding anything to [the complainant’s] entry”.
6. The
complainant provided a list of eight SNP MSPs with their entries from the
“Remuneration and related undertaking” section of the Register of Interests.
She stated that this showed there were other SNP MSPs aside from her who could
be said to have a “second job”.
Relevant
Code Provisions
Clause 1
(Accuracy)
i) The
Press must take care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorted
information or images, including headlines not supported by the text.
ii) A
significant inaccuracy, misleading statement or distortion must be corrected,
promptly and with due prominence, and — where appropriate — an apology
published. In cases involving IPSO, due prominence should be as required by the
regulator.
iii) A
fair opportunity to reply to significant inaccuracies should be given, when
reasonably called for.
iv) The
Press, while free to editorialise and campaign, must distinguish clearly
between comment, conjecture and fact.
Mediated
Outcome
7. The
complaint was not resolved through direct correspondence between the parties.
IPSO therefore began an investigation into the matter.
8.
During IPSO’s investigation the publication offered to print the following
correction:
Michelle
Thomson MSP
In an
article published in The Herald on Monday November 15 headlined: MSPs holding
second jobs using Holyrood for ‘hobby’ says Labour, we stated that ’seven
Scottish Conservative MSPs and one SNP MSP had second jobs alongside their
Holyrood job and salary”. That was incorrect as we failed to highlight that in
compiling the list, drawn from MSPs’ entries in the register of interest, we
had excluded 10 sitting SNP local councillors elected to Holyrood: Siobhian
Brown MSP, Stephanie Callaghan MSP, Natalie Don MSP, Jackie Dunbar MSP, Jenny
Gilruth MSP, Paul McLennan MSP, Marie McNair, Audrey Nicoll, Emma Roddick MSP,
Collette Stevenson MSP, Evelyn Tweed MSP and Elena Whitham MSP. In addition we
had not included Emma Harper SNP MSP who does voluntary work as a registered
nurse and as a member of the NHS vaccination team. We should have either made
that clear or included them all and we apologise to Mrs Thomson for wrongly
singling her out as the only SNP MSP who had a second job alongside their
Holyrood job and salary.
9. The
complainant said that this would resolve the matter to her satisfaction.
10. As
the complaint was successfully mediated, the Complaints Committee did not make
a determination as to whether there had been any breach of the Code.
Date
complaint received: 16/11/2021
Date complaint concluded by IPSO: 24/01/2022
Back to ruling listing